 | 1939: Lawrence "Sharky" Moore (Founder, Originator) |
| 1940: David O. "Mutt" Sullivan |
| 1941: Harold Hanes |
| 1942: Roy Heard |
| 1943: Henry Steele (First President, Stony Creek Horsemen's Assoc.) |
| 1944: David O. "Mutt" Sullivan |
| 1945: Lawrence "Sharky" Moore |
| 1946: Lawrence "Sharky" Moore |
| 1947: Earl Moore |
| 1948: Al Chapman |
| 1949: Roy Heard |
| 1950: Earl Moore |
| 1951: Lee Sconyers |
| 1952: Lee Sconyers |
| 1953-1958: Lawrence "Sharky" Moore |
| 1959: Denny Ellerman |
| 1960-1969: Lawrence "Sharky" Moore |
| 1970-1973: Richard "Dick" Moore |
| 1974-1977: Tom Fisher |
| 1978-1980: Kay Fisher (First Woman President) |
| 1981-1982: Barney Cook |
| 1983-1985: Ray Williams |
| 1986-1987: Morris Moody |
| 1988-1990: Zoe Brandenberger |
| 1991-1992: Al Stanchina |
| 1993: Joe Williams |
| 1994: Joe Williams |
| 1995: Barney Cook |
| 1996: Barney Cook |
| 1997: Al Andrade |
| 1998: Al Andrade |
| 1999: Butch Matteson |
| 2000: Butch Matteson |
| 2001 to Present: Zoe Brandenberger |
